Choosing a Wireless Technology: BLE, Wi-Fi, LoRaWAN or Cellular

Every wireless technology is a compromise between how far it reaches, how much data it carries and how much energy it uses. Bluetooth Low Energy sips power but covers a room. Wi-Fi moves megabits and needs a wall socket or a large battery. LoRaWAN reaches kilometres at a few bytes a minute. Choosing well means starting from what the product has to send, how often, and what it runs on.

At a glance

2.4 GHz
The worldwide licence-free band shared by Bluetooth, Wi-Fi, Zigbee and Thread.
2 Mbps
Maximum data rate of the Bluetooth Low Energy 2M PHY.
250 kbps
Data rate of IEEE 802.15.4, the radio beneath Zigbee and Thread.
Sub-GHz
LoRaWAN uses 868 MHz in Europe and 915 MHz in North America for long range.

The problem

Teams often pick the radio they know and discover its limits later: a Wi-Fi sensor that needs its battery changed monthly, or a Bluetooth device that cannot reach the gateway two rooms away.

The radio also brings obligations beyond the link itself: an antenna that needs board area and tuning, regulatory approval in every market, and for cellular, a subscription and operator certification.

Start from the payload, the interval and the power source. The radio that fits those three usually chooses itself.

Reading the trade-off

Lower frequencies travel further and pass through walls better, which is why sub-GHz technologies achieve long range. Higher data rates need more bandwidth and more transmit energy per second, though less time on air per byte.

Using a pre-certified radio module rather than a chip-down design greatly reduces regulatory work, at a higher unit cost. For low and medium volumes that trade is usually worth making.

What good looks like

Write down the payload size, how often it is sent, the range required and the power source.

Shortlist the technologies that meet all four and compare module cost, infrastructure and approvals.

Prototype the link in a realistic environment before committing; radio performance on paper and in a building differ.

Wireless technologies compared
TechnologyBandData rateTypical range
Bluetooth LE2.4 GHz125 kbps - 2 MbpsTens of metres
Zigbee / Thread2.4 GHz250 kbpsTens of metres, extended by mesh
Wi-Fi2.4 / 5 / 6 GHzMbps to GbpsTens of metres
LoRaWAN868 / 915 MHz0.3 - 50 kbpsKilometres
LTE-MLicensed cellularAbout 1 MbpsCellular coverage
NB-IoTLicensed cellularTens to hundreds of kbpsCellular coverage, deep indoor
Nominal figures from the standards. Real range and throughput depend on environment, antenna and regulations.
Bluetooth LE and Wi-Fi
Bluetooth LEWi-Fi
Power consumptionVery lowHigh
Data rateUp to 2 MbpsMbps to Gbps
Direct internet accessNeeds a phone or gatewayBuilt in
Coin-cell operationPracticalNot practical
The two most common choices for consumer devices.

What it changes

Battery Life

A radio matched to the duty cycle keeps average current within the energy budget.

Coverage

The link works at the distances and through the obstacles the product will actually meet.

Certification

Approvals are planned from the start, with modules used where they save time.

Running Cost

Subscription, gateway and infrastructure costs are known before the choice is made.

Where to go next

Budget board area for the antenna and its keep-out zone at the start of mechanical design. It cannot be squeezed in afterwards.

Decide how firmware will be updated over the chosen link. Low-rate networks make large updates slow or impractical.

Problems this prevents

  • A power-hungry radio on a small battery
  • Range that falls short in real buildings
  • Approvals discovered late in the project
  • No room left for the antenna

Discuss your project

Email support@aavico.com or use Get in Touch when the website finishes loading.