Grounding and Return Paths: Why Split Planes Cause Trouble

Every signal current returns to its source, and on a circuit board the path it takes back decides much of the board’s noise performance. A common instinct in mixed-signal design is to split the ground plane into analogue and digital regions to keep them apart. In many designs that creates the very coupling it was meant to prevent. This article explains how return current behaves and how to get isolation without cutting the plane.

At a glance

1 plane
A single solid ground plane suits most mixed-signal boards, given careful placement.
50%
Of the return current lies within one dielectric height either side of a trace, idealised.
Least L
At high frequency, return current takes the path of least inductance, directly under the trace.
Stitching
Vias or capacitors that give return current a path where a signal changes reference plane.

The problem

At low frequency, return current spreads out and follows the path of least resistance. At higher frequency it follows the path of least inductance, which lies directly beneath the signal trace on the adjacent plane. For the fast edges of modern digital signals, the second case applies.

When a trace crosses a gap in its reference plane, the return current cannot follow it. It detours around the end of the gap, creating a large loop that radiates and picks up noise, and the gap itself can behave as a slot antenna.

Do not decide where the ground currents go by cutting copper. Decide it by where you place the parts.

Partition, do not split

Keep the ground plane continuous and separate circuits by placement instead. Put analogue components together and digital components together, and route each section’s signals only over its own area. Return currents then stay under their own signals and do not cross.

Mixed-signal converter datasheets often recommend connecting the analogue and digital ground pins to the same plane at the device. Where a split is truly required, for example a safety isolation barrier, no signal should cross it without a planned path such as an isolator or a stitching capacitor.

What good looks like

Place the board in sections by function, with converters sitting at the boundary between analogue and digital areas.

Keep the ground plane solid and check that no signal routes over a gap, a slot or a dense field of vias.

Where a signal changes layers onto a different reference plane, add a ground via or a stitching capacitor next to the signal via.

Return current near a microstrip trace
%
±1 h50
±2 h70.5
±3 h79.5
±5 h87.4
±10 h93.7
Share of return current within the stated distance of the trace centre, where h is the trace height above the plane. Calculated for an idealised microstrip over an infinite plane.
Split and solid ground planes
Split planeSolid plane
Return path for crossing signalsDetours around the gapDirectly under the trace
Loop areaLarge where signals crossSmall
How sections are isolatedBy the gapBy placement
Safety isolation barrierPossibleNot possible
For most mixed-signal boards a solid plane with careful placement performs better.

What it changes

Lower Emissions

Return loops stay small, so the board radiates less.

Quieter Analogue

Digital return currents do not flow through analogue areas.

Simpler Layout

One plane is easier to route over than several islands.

Predictable Behaviour

Controlled return paths make noise problems easier to diagnose.

Where to go next

Watch for unintentional splits as well: rows of closely spaced vias or a connector footprint can cut a plane as effectively as a drawn gap.

Chassis and safety earth are a separate question from signal ground, planned at system level.

Problems this prevents

  • Signals routed across gaps in the ground plane
  • Analogue noise from digital return currents
  • Slots formed by rows of closely spaced vias
  • Layer changes with no nearby return via

Discuss your project

Email support@aavico.com or use Get in Touch when the website finishes loading.