Linear Regulator or Switching Converter? Choosing a Power Supply

Every board has to turn its input voltage into the rails its circuits use, and the two basic ways of doing it trade efficiency against simplicity and noise. A linear regulator drops the excess voltage across a pass transistor as heat. A switching converter stores energy in an inductor and transfers it in pulses. Neither is always better, and many good designs use both. This article explains how to choose.

At a glance

Vout/Vin
The best possible efficiency of a linear regulator, since input and output current are nearly equal.
Dropout
The minimum input-to-output difference a linear regulator needs to stay in regulation.
PSRR
Power supply rejection ratio: how well a regulator stops input ripple reaching its output.
85-95%
A typical efficiency range for synchronous buck converters at moderate load, per datasheet curves.

The problem

The cost of a linear regulator is heat. Dropping 12 V to 3.3 V at 500 mA dissipates about 4.35 W in the regulator, more than most small packages can shed without a heatsink, and the supply or battery pays for every watt.

The cost of a switching converter is noise and layout care. It switches current at hundreds of kilohertz to several megahertz, producing output ripple and potential emissions, and it needs an inductor and careful placement.

Work out the power the regulator will dissipate before choosing it. That single number settles most of these decisions.

Where each one fits

A linear regulator suits small voltage drops, low currents and noise-sensitive loads such as ADC references, oscillators and RF circuits. Low-dropout types work with a few hundred millivolts of headroom or less, and their output is free of switching ripple.

A switching converter suits large voltage ratios, higher currents and battery products where efficiency sets run time. A common pattern combines the two: a buck converter does the bulk conversion efficiently, and a low-dropout regulator after it cleans up the rail for a sensitive load.

What good looks like

For each rail, calculate the linear regulator dissipation as the voltage drop times the load current, at the highest input voltage.

If the dissipation or the lost efficiency is unacceptable, choose a switching converter and plan its layout and filtering.

For noise-sensitive loads, check ripple and PSRR at the frequencies that matter, and add a post-regulator or filter where needed.

Best-case linear regulator efficiency to 3.3 V
%
From 3.6 V91.7
From 5 V66
From 9 V36.7
From 12 V27.5
From 24 V13.7
Calculated as Vout divided by Vin, ignoring quiescent current. Real efficiency is slightly lower.
Linear and switching regulators
LinearSwitching
Efficiency with a large dropLowHigh
Output noiseVery lowSwitching ripple
Parts countRegulator and capacitorsAdds an inductor and more capacitors
Can step voltage upNoYes
Layout sensitivityLowHigh
General characteristics. Specific devices vary.

What it changes

Thermal Control

Regulator heat is known and handled before layout.

Battery Run Time

Efficient conversion turns more stored energy into useful work.

Clean Rails

Sensitive circuits get the low noise they need.

Lower Cost

Simple linear regulators are used wherever they are good enough.

Where to go next

Check the light-load behaviour of switching converters. Many enter pulse-skipping or burst modes at light load, which changes the ripple spectrum.

Board layout decides whether a switching converter performs as its datasheet promises. Keep the high-current switching loop as small as possible.

Problems this prevents

  • Linear regulators overheating at high input
  • Battery life lost to wasted heat
  • Switching ripple on sensitive analogue rails
  • A converter added late with no room for layout

Discuss your project

Email support@aavico.com or use Get in Touch when the website finishes loading.