PCB Surface Finishes Compared: HASL, ENIG, OSP and More
Bare copper oxidises within days, and oxidised copper does not solder. Every board therefore ships with a finish over its exposed pads. The choice affects assembly yield, how long boards can be stored, and whether the finish is suitable for fine-pitch components, edge connectors or wire bonding. This article compares the finishes you will be offered and gives a way to choose.
At a glance
- ENIG
- Electroless nickel immersion gold: flat, durable and the common default for fine-pitch work.
- HASL
- Hot air solder levelling: economical and robust, but uneven on small pads.
- OSP
- Organic solderability preservative: flat and low cost, with the shortest storage life.
- RoHS
- Lead-free finishes are required for products sold under RoHS rules.
The problem
Hot air levelling leaves a slightly domed, uneven coating. On large pads that does not matter. Under a fine-pitch BGA or a 0.4 mm pitch QFN, the height variation between pads causes opens and bridges.
Flat finishes solve that but each has a weakness: OSP degrades with handling and repeated heating, immersion silver tarnishes if stored badly, and ENIG costs more and needs a well-controlled process.
Choose the finish for your finest-pitch part and your storage time. Everything else on the board will be fine with it.
How to choose
If the board has BGAs, fine-pitch QFNs or other parts with pitch at or below 0.5 mm, choose a flat finish; ENIG is the usual choice. If everything is larger and cost matters most, lead-free HASL is a sound option.
If boards will sit in storage before assembly, check the shelf life of the finish with your fabricator and keep boards in their sealed packaging until use.
What good looks like
Find the finest-pitch component and any special requirements such as edge fingers, press-fit connectors or wire bonding.
Choose the lowest-cost finish that meets those requirements and the expected storage time.
Specify the finish on the fabrication drawing and tell the assembler, since it affects their reflow settings.
| Finish | Surface | Fine pitch | Relative cost |
|---|---|---|---|
| Lead-free HASL | Uneven | Limited | Low |
| OSP | Flat | Good | Low |
| Immersion silver | Flat | Good | Medium |
| Immersion tin | Flat | Good | Medium |
| ENIG | Flat | Very good | Higher |
| ENEPIG | Flat | Very good, wire-bondable | Highest |
| Lead-free HASL | ENIG | |
|---|---|---|
| Cost | Lower | Higher |
| Pad flatness | Uneven | Flat |
| Fine-pitch and BGA | Limited | Well suited |
| Rework tolerance | Robust | Good |
| Storage | Good | Long |
What it changes
Assembly Yield
A finish matched to the pad geometry removes a common cause of opens and bridges.
Shelf Life
Boards stay solderable for as long as the build plan needs.
Cost
The premium for a flat finish is paid only where the design requires it.
Compliance
A lead-free finish keeps the bare board within RoHS requirements.
Where to go next
Edge connectors that are plugged repeatedly need hard gold on the contact fingers, which is specified separately from the board finish.
If your assembler reports solderability problems, check the board date code and storage conditions before changing the finish.
Problems this prevents
- Bridging under fine-pitch parts from an uneven finish
- Boards that will not solder after long storage
- Paying for ENIG on a board that does not need it
- A leaded finish on a RoHS product
Discuss your project
Email support@aavico.com or use Get in Touch when the website finishes loading.