Testing Assembled Boards: AOI, X-Ray, ICT and Functional Test

An assembled board can fail in many ways: a missing part, a wrong value, a joint that looks fine and is open, firmware that will not boot. Each inspection and test method sees some of these and is blind to others. Planning test alongside the design, rather than after it, is what makes high coverage affordable. This article explains what each method finds and how to combine them.

At a glance

AOI
Automated optical inspection: cameras check presence, placement, polarity and visible joints.
X-ray
Sees hidden joints under BGAs and QFNs, including voids and bridges.
ICT
In-circuit test: probes measure component values and find shorts and opens.
FCT
Functional test: powers the board and checks that it actually does its job.

The problem

Optical inspection cannot see under a BGA. In-circuit test needs a probe point on every net, which a dense board may not have. Functional test confirms the board works but rarely says which component is at fault when it does not.

Leaving test until the design is finished makes it expensive. Without test points, programming access and a way to exercise each function, the only option left is slow manual checking.

Decide how each board will be proven good before the layout is finished. Test access is free at design time and costly afterwards.

Matching method to volume

For prototypes and small batches, a flying probe tester gives electrical coverage without a dedicated fixture. For volume production, a bed-of-nails in-circuit fixture costs more to build but tests each board in seconds.

Whatever the volume, a functional test that programs the device and checks its interfaces is worth having. It is the test closest to what the customer will experience.

What good looks like

List the fault types that matter for your product and map each to a method that can detect it.

Add test points, programming headers and any test firmware to the design while there is room.

Agree the test plan and pass criteria with the assembler, including what is recorded for each serial number.

What each method finds
MethodFindsDoes not find
AOIMissing, misplaced or reversed parts; visible joint defectsHidden joints; electrical faults
X-rayVoids, bridges and opens under BGAs and QFNsWrong component values
Flying probeShorts, opens, component valuesDynamic or functional faults; slower per board
ICTShorts, opens, values, some device testsFaults on nets without probe access
Functional testWhether the board performs its functionThe location of the fault
General capability of each method. Coverage depends on the board and the test design.
Flying probe and in-circuit fixture
Flying probeICT fixture
Set-up costLowHigh
Time per boardMinutesSeconds
Design changesProgram updateNew fixture
Best forPrototypes, low volumeVolume production
Two ways of making the same electrical measurements.

What it changes

Coverage

Each fault type is caught by at least one method, leaving few escapes.

Diagnosis

Electrical test localises faults, which makes rework quick.

Cost per Board

Test planned into the design runs in seconds rather than minutes.

Traceability

Recorded results link each unit to the evidence that it passed.

Where to go next

Boundary scan can test connections to large digital parts where probing is impossible, if the devices support it and the chain is brought out.

Review test results across batches. A defect that recurs points at the design or the process, not at chance.

Problems this prevents

  • Hidden joints that were never inspected
  • No test points on a dense board
  • A functional test that cannot isolate faults
  • Faulty boards discovered by the customer

Discuss your project

Email support@aavico.com or use Get in Touch when the website finishes loading.